Skip to main content

Bilge reinforcement - Part 1

There was delamination at the floor beam-to-hull attachments, probably due to earlier groundings and we could also see the swinging/pendulum keel symptom when the boat was transported with the keel hanging. It was time to do something about it. The plan is to reinforce the whole keel-to-hull joint with 3-4 layers of 600g biaxial fiberglass cloth, re-bond the floor beams to the hull with at least 6 layers and add new structural members to stiffen up the construction against side loads.

This is how the delamination looked like:


In the fall of 2019 we started the keel/bilge reinforcement project. It took several weekends to sand everything and it was probably the most difficult boat work (or any type of work really 😃) I ever did. 
I killed one orbital sander and one vacuum cleaner during the job. Then I bought a cheap vac with HEPA filter from Biltema, which turned to be a really good choice. The high density filter is really a must to catch the very fine fiberglass dust. 


We considered cutting and lifting the cabin sole to have better access to the bilge, but as Ann-Riis has a teak floor the removal of which would require removing the saloon interior, and cutting openings in the wood would look really ugly, we decided trying completing the job without it. Which means really poor access to the port side of the bilge. You really need "snake-man" hands.  

For most of the somewhat flat and curvy surfaces I used an orbital sander with 40 grid paper which is a slow way of doing it, but gives more control over how much of the material you remove. At corners and places where I had to remove lots of material (de-laminated floor beam attachments), I used a thin belt sander. I can strongly recommend buying one for this job, I wouldn't have been able to reach many areas without it and it was quite easy to work with.

I also tried an angle grinder with sanding attachments but it was just too brutal and hard to control, it removes too much material and blows out all the dust. I guess I could have bought a vacuum cleaner attachment to it, which makes the dust situation manageable, but with bad access, where you can use only one hand the angle grinder is dangerous too. For some really tight places with even worse access (around the mast step), I used a battery powered multi-tool and had to squeeze my hand through the mast and saloon table's leg openings.
 

After maybe the 3rd weekend of sanding, completely exhausted, I thought I'm finally done. But then I found another overlooked de-laminated area in the galley... Although it's not structural, I decided to fix it anyway to finish all the dusty work at once.


Before sanding the bottom of the bilge, I removed the keel nuts, which was not as difficult as I expected. Maybe the nuts were not tightened properly, I'm not sure. I used a long lever wrench and had to use my whole body weight on it, but it was doable. For re-tightening I bought a torque-wrench and will tighten the nuts to 210Nm. We'll see if it can be done with the access we have. I saw that some Scanmar 33 owners drilled holes in the cabin sole above the keel bolts to be able to tighten them properly, but that's something I would like to avoid. We're planning to replace the backing plates (washers) on the keel bolt rods to a little bit bigger, thicker and square ones.

Now we have to wait until the weather will be favorable again for epoxy, then start laying up the laminate to reinforce the bottom part of the keel-to-hull joint ("floor" of the bilge). Then the new keel-bolt backing plates can be installed and the nuts re-tightened. After that hopefully the boat can be carefully moved in the spring. As we're going to install new structural members and would like to avoid building in stress into the laminate, we would like to do it with either more support or while the boat is in the water, so that she's not standing on her keel.

The plan at the moment is to add two new structural members one of which will be placed roughly between the two middle floor beams and the other one at the aft side of the rear floor beam. They will be only half the height, so we'll still have access to the keel bolts with a wrench from the existing floor openings above them.

Comments

  1. Very nice boat and welldone job. Do you have pic of this wonderfull compartment where batteries, boiler are? Owner manual?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks. I don't really have good pictures of the storage/engine compartment yet. You can see an old picture of it that I made when I bought the boat here:
      https://drive.google.com/file/d/1yiZ5BKK7r5Mm8y295qe1aGyaDkNYT3KV/view?usp=sharing
      There is a heater unit in the back, the diesel tank on the left and boiler on the right, can be seen here:
      https://4.bp.blogspot.com/-f8zGnrP4LLg/XwF9APa9vKI/AAAAAAAAYAM/NGfmKofzKZAysEqX_2LBuW07suCdi9muQCLcBGAsYHQ/s1600/IMG_0429-e1570697328494.jpg

      There is a shelf between the diesel tank and the bulkhead to store various things. The engine starter battery is on the floor, behind the steering rod.

      Most of the electrical stuff is on the bulkhead next to the diesel tank:
      https://2.bp.blogspot.com/-pu6NqMbRzME/XwJGdMX-g0I/AAAAAAAAYGY/cFzEKKavFxsKDI9JCebY-uuX6EKnB3TNQCLcBGAsYHQ/s640/IMG_9854-scaled.jpg

      I have the original Swedish owner's manual on the boat. I was planning to scan it, but couldn't get to the office to do it since covid.

      Delete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Bilge reinforcement - Part 2

Read Part 1 After careful surface preparation the bilge reinforcement project continued with laying the new laminate. I consulted with West System on what fabric to use and they suggested biaxial cloth without chopped strand matting. The biaxial cloth is very strong and CSM would just add weight. We bought 600g biaxial cloth with 45/45 degree strands from Composite24 and West System 105 epoxy with 206 fast hardener at a local marine store. Cutting fabric The work was done in sections, we started with the bilge bottom while the keel nuts and washers were removed. It got 4 layers that come up 10cm at the bilge sides. This area gets most of the load and we wanted to reinforce it by connecting the fabric on the bottom to the fabric layed on the sides. 4 layers on the bottom In theory these types of reinforcements are suggested to be done either with the keel dropped or while the keel is hanging so it's not compressing the joint while the boat is standing on th

New ventillators and smoke detector

Three old ventillators have been replaced last weekend as they were falling apart due to UV damage and the brittle plastic. We could get the exact same type of ventillators, so we went with those. No new holes to drill and hopefully these will do the job for another 10 years. I was also considering changing them to solar vents, but I haven't read too good reviews about them. They're usually much bigger (need a bigger hole) and according to many they tend to die after a year or two (either the battery or the fan motor gets loud) and doesn't worth the extra price tag.  We're going to add some regular 12V car fans inside before we sail to warmer climates. We already have a gas/propane alarm in the galley and now I also installed a battery powered smoke detector. Very easy and no drilling required, it's held in place with velcro strips.