Skip to main content

Scanmar bilge and swinging keel

The Scanmars, at least the SC33 and SC35 that I'm aware of, are infamous of developing a swinging/pendulum keel due to the lack of structural members in the bilge that could prevent the hull from flexing sideways at the hull to keel joint.

Here is an article (in Swedish) that mentions this problem (svajköl), and here is another one from a surveyor who claims it's a weakness in the construction.

The "stringers" on these boats are only floor beams, that are not going down deep enough to the bilge to act as a structural element. If the boat was grounded hard, the attachments of the floor beams could delaminate from the hull, making the hull-keel joint even weaker and the swinging keel symptom worse.

When we were on a boat hunt we've checked out almost all the SC33 on the market at the time and paid attention to how their bilges looked like (and in the end bought a SC35 without reinforcements 😄). As the bilge on the SC33 and SC35 looks very similar, I thought it might be interesting to see how the bilge looks like on various Scanmars.

Some owners were claiming that there were no symptom of swinging keels, (we couldn't verify the claims though without lifting the boat). Others reinforced the bilge either on their own or done by a yard. To be able to spot a swinging keel, the easiest way is if the boat is lifted and moved around a bit by the crane to develop enough momentum. If the crane is a rolling one, standing on the ground around the boat (to prevent the whole boat from moving), it's also possible to push the keel hard and spot a few centimeters of play. Note: the play may also come from loose keel bolts, so double check those too.

I also heard that the issue is affecting only the first two years of production, later the yard claimed that they reinforced the construction and eliminated the issue. I'm not convinced about this as many owners did reinforce their boats even though they were from 1984 (4th year of production) and we saw boats from 1984 without any reinforcements too.

Examples of various Scanmar 33 bilge structures:

#1
Scanmar 33 bilge from 1984, floor beams and keel bolts seem original, without any serious reinforcements.

#2
Another Scanmar 33 bilge, probably original, without reinforcement. Interestingly the floor beam is even weakened by "hole drills", not sure why or if it's original (to have more storage in the bilge, or to have better access to tighten the bolts?). 

#3
This example of Scanmar 33 is from 1983 with added reinforcements. The floor beams are glassed down to the bilge and a "new" structural member (the thinner one on the left) is added. 

Another view of the same boat's bilge, note the cut in the cabin sole that had to be lifted to gain access to work on the other port side of the reinforcement.

#4
Another Scanmar 33 from 1984. Also a good example of added reinforcements. New, somewhat thinner structural member added between the existing floor beams. 

Different angle of the same boat, with better view of the glassed down floor beam. 

One more image of the same boat, the smaller "beam" towards the bow is original, it's the platform where the keel steped mast is standing. Looks the same on our Scanmar 35 too. 

#5
This is another Scanmar 33 where reinforcement was added possibly to prevent the swinging keel. I assume this work was done by the owner. Thin, small beam glassed in between the original floor beams, the cabin sole was cut and lifted. 

Same boat, I sadly forgot to note the production year, but I think it was from the first few years. Better view of the added beam and the original floor beams here. 

#6
This Scanmar 33 (year unknown) had reinforced stainless steel plates under the keel bolts. I think they didn't change the keel bolt rods to longer ones (not sure if it could be easily done or not). At the plate towards the bow (on the right) it seems that the bolts are not long enough to properly secure the nuts, also it looks like some delamination might have started to occur above the plate at the corner. Could be due to a grounding? 

Same boat with the reinforced keel bolt backing plates. The beams were also extended down to the bottom of the bilge (on the left).


During the fall we're planning to reinforce the bilge on Ann-Riis by laying extra layers of fiberglass over the existing beams to have a strong bond to the hull and possibly bringing them down to the bottom of the bilge. We also have to consider keeping the access to the keel bolts, which are basically M20 stainless steel threaded rods screwed into the keel and secured with a backing plate and a nut inside. We're also thinking about adding an extra, smaller structural member. I'm not sure yet if we can manage do it without cutting the cabin sole and/or removing parts of the interior. Stay tuned.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Bilge reinforcement - Part 2

Read Part 1
After careful surface preparation the bilge reinforcement project continued with laying the new laminate. I consulted with West System on what fabric to use and they suggested biaxial cloth without chopped strand matting. The biaxial cloth is very strong and CSM would just add weight. We bought 600g biaxial cloth with 45/45 degree strands from Composite24 and West System 105 epoxy with 206 fast hardener at a local marine store.
Cutting fabric
The work was done in sections, we started with the bilge bottom/floor while the keel nuts and washers were removed. It got 4 layers that come up 10cm at the bilge sides. This area gets most of the loads and we wanted to reinforce it by connecting the fabric on the bottom to the one to be layed on the sides.

In theory these types of reinforcements are suggested to be done either with the keel dropped or while the keel is hanging so it's not compressing the joint while the boat is standing on the keel. The idea is to avoid building …

Bilge reinforcement - Part 1

Ann-Riis had delamination at the floor beam to hull attachments probably due to earlier groundings and we could also see the swinging/pendulum keel symptom when the boat was transported with the keel hanging. It was time to do something about it. The plan is to reinforce the whole keel-to-hull joint with 3-4 layers of 600g biaxial fiberglass cloth, re-bond the floor beams to the hull with at least 6 layers and add new structural members to stiffen up the construction against side loads.

Delamination:


In the fall of 2019 we started the keel/bilge reinforcement project. It took several weekends to sand everything and it was probably the most difficult boat work (or any type of work really 😃) I ever did. I covered the working area with plastic protective foil, but it didn't do much. The fiberglass dust was so intense that after a while the tape holding the foil was falling off and the dust covered every corner of the boat. I killed one orbital sander and one vacuum cleaner during …

Electrical refit - Part 1

The electrical system on the boat was in a very sad condition and needed a refit. As it's often the case on older boats, the previous owners just added new stuff without really improving the system or thinking it through. Worst of all, they didn't used marine grade materials or did the installation right either. They just applied quick fixes and left it that way. We were planning to rewire the boat completely during this fall, but as it turned out, it couldn't wait. When I started the engine before heading out for a one week sail, the battery warning light came up. According to the manual the light might indicate incorrect voltage from the generator. When I checked it with a multi-meter, it was very high indeed, well over 15V, so it was overcharging the batteries, which carries the risk of gas leakage or explosion. So we decided to investigate it further and delay our departure for vacation. After disconnecting the house bank, the alternator output normalized, so we conc…